Monday, February 23, 2015

NASCAR's flawed Green-White-Checkered rule needs to be fixed and here's how to do it

The ending of yesterday's Daytona 500 was the perfect ending to a wild weekend of racing at the World Center of Speed. The race - which was remarkably clean after a week of destruction and off-track controversy - ended under caution a mile short of the finish line due to a crash on the backstretch and has left NASCAR Nation embroiled in debate.

Let me be clear about this right up front: the caution flag was the right thing to do. Kyle Larson did indeed make significant contact with the inside wall. Safety crews needed to be dispatched. So the the caution was the right call in that moment.

But that caution also brought the race to a premature end. That's right, a race run with a green-white-checkered rule to ensure a green flag finish ended under the caution.

How can that be?

NASCAR's rules state that once the white flag is thrown, should the caution come out at any time, the field is frozen and the race is over.

So the race could end inches past the start-finish line on the last lap, as it did in the 2005 Truck race at Daytona. Or it could end somewhere down the backstretch, as it did yesterday. Or it could end off of turn four, as it did last year when Dale Earnhardt won. The fact is no one knows when a race might end, especially at a restrictor plate track.

And in a sport that prides itself on being fair and offering a level playing field, that is remarkably UNFAIR. And not only that, it leaves your fans - those that have invested thousands of dollars to be there and those that have invested hours of their time to watch at home - with an empty feeling at the end.

It has been said repeatedly over the past 24 hours that calling that last lap caution and ending a race prematurely is the toughest call in NASCAR to make. "No one wants to see a race end under the caution," is what NASCAR Chairman and CEO Brian France said to Jim Noble and Chocolate Myers on Sirius XM NASCAR Radio today. Okay, so let's fix it. Let's take the "do we or don't we" debate out of it. Let's make it a cut-and-dried scenario.

The easiest solution for this is the way the rule should have been written from Day One. If the caution comes out on the last lap, the field is frozen, the pace car is sent out, and they line up for another attempt at a green-white-checkered. That way there is never a debate of whether to throw a caution on the last lap. That way we can get safety crews out to drivers that need attention. That way we don't have to wait hours to get official results as we review scoring loop data and video and photo evidence to try to give our best guess on where everyone was when the caution came out. And that way we as an industry deliver what we have told fans we will give them: a race that finishes under the green flag. And we line them up and do that green white checkered as many times as it takes to get the field under the checkered under the green.

As Jeff Gordon pointed out on Twitter, that could present some issues for teams, particularly when fuel is an issue at the end. The simple answer to that is "that's racing."

It's understandable that people might think you would go through a never-ending cycle of green-white-checkered attempts because aggressive drivers will do whatever it takes to win and that would result in crash after crash after crash. Many point to the Truck Series race at Gateway in 2004 as their evidence since that race had a record four attempts at the GWC before the finish.

But what is overlooked is that it was an amazing race with a last corner of the last lap pass for the win that left the fans buzzing afterward.

Others will say "well, if you have unlimited green-white-checkereds it will look like an ARCA race!" You mean the ARCA series that has unlimited GWC attempts and has never gone more than three attempts to get to the checkered? If the lowly ARCA series can get it done in three or less attempts, surely the greatest stock car drivers in the world can do it too.

If we are going to allow races to end under the caution, then let's do away with the GWC rule and end races at the advertised distance, as suggested by Kyle Petty. I have no problem with that either. We did it for 50+ years and no one ever debated the legitimacy of a winner that took the checkered under the caution. But once we started red flagging races late to preserve a green flag finish, it became obvious a GWC rule was going to be necessary.

Dave Moody said on his program on Sirius XM NASCAR Radio this afternoon "No one wants to see a race end under the yellow. If you asked us all, 100% of us want to see every race end under the green flag." Okay, so let's work to that solution. The problem isn't throwing the caution on the last lap, it's what happens when the caution flag is thrown. So let's do what we say we are going to do and give the fans in the stands and those watching at home a green flag finish.

NASCAR proved it can make quick corrections when, along with Daytona International Speedway, they worked to put energy-absorbing barriers where Kyle Busch had his horrendous crash on Saturday. They should work equally fast to fix what has been a flawed green-white-checkered rule from the very day it was implemented.

5 comments:

  1. Or you cold have a system which freezes the field from the wreck on back and allowing the cars in front of the crash to finish their lap. They could dispatch the safety crew right away to the crash as long as it's not too close to the finish line. This could bring back racing to the line in a safe way.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Jay Tonsager: How is that fair to anyone but the front runners? A lot can happen in 3 laps. We all know that.
    NASCAR needs to finish the race under green - as promised. Truth in advertising and all that.
    I agree with Cone on this one. Why is it different on the last lap than it is on lap 3 or 2?
    If a caution is thrown freeze the field and restart - period.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Jennifer Swarbrick: You can still have the GWC rule with racing to the line but I think once the white flag is thrown it should be the last lap. Too many GWC drag the race on. The leaders should be able to finish their lap if it's safe like the old days.

      Delete
  3. Makes sense. I'd pay to see that, and I think it increases the intensity even more.

    ReplyDelete